Clean Yogurts

Clean Yogurts

20 comments

Hang with me, there is a lot to say about yogurt.  Let’s start with the process that turns milk into yogurt.  Yogurt is made through the fermentation process.  Fermentation is the process of adding yeast or bacteria to turn carbohydrates into alcohol and carbon dioxide, or acids.  Live, active bacteria are added to milk causing the milk’s sugar to turn into lactic acid.  That acid gives it the tangy, distinct flavor.

Fermented foods, while they may not sound so appealing, have many vital health benefits.  By eating fermented foods, yogurt for example, you are adding good bacteria to your gut.  These bacterias help to break down food, and allow your body to absorb more nutrition.  Adding fermented food to diets has shown to help aid digestion, build a strong immune system, and everything from Multiple Sclerosis, and Colitis, to Constipation, and Asthma.  This is where yogurt gets its good health reputation.  It is a fermented food that contains beneficial bacteria, and also is a good source of calcium.  Unfortunately, most store bought yogurts have additives that cancel out any of the good.

One additive in particular comes to mind now – carrageenan.  This has been in articles lately, and until recently I thought it was harmless in food, after all it’s a derivative of red seaweed and can be found in organic foods.  But studies have shown this causes inflammation in the gastrointestinal tract, and possibly even cancer.  And the additives don’t stop there.  You can find a rainbow of food dyes, high fructose corn syrup, and aspartame.  Please do not assume yogurt is good for you.  Yes, foods and drinks made through the fermentation process are very beneficial to our health, but the additives have to stop!

Greek Yogurt is made by straining the liquid whey, which give you a thick, creamy, protein concentrated yogurt.  It takes up to three times more milk to make, which is the reason it is so much more expensive.  Greek yogurts have lower lactose amounts, so they may be a good option for anyone who is lactose intolerant.  Greek yogurt, on average, has twice as much protein as regular yogurt, and usually less sugar, when comparing the plain varieties.

There are also dairy-free yogurt alternatives, such as soy, almond, and coconut yogurts.  Just make sure you check the labels, just as you should with the dairy yogurts.

Here’s what you don’t want to see on the label of your yogurt:

  • Aspartame - This is a very dangerous additive and should always be avoided in any food or drinks.  Aspartame has three components: methanol, phenylalanine, and aspartic acid. All three of these chemicals have each been shown to either stimulate brain cells to death, severely disrupt hormone balances in the brain, or act as a dangerous nerve poison.  Scary stuff!  It was in about 75% of the yogurt I looked at, except Greek Yogurt and Organic yogurts.
  • Artificial Food Dyes – Not only are artificial food dyes linked to behavioral problems, diabetes, obesity, and asthma, the three most used food dyes (red-40, yellow-5, and yellow-6) contain cancer causing substances.  Most food dyes are also petroleum based, and something you do not want in your food — even in the smallest amount.
  • Carrageenan - This additive has come under fire lately, especially for it’s use in organic products.  It sounds harmless, it’s a derivative of red seaweed, and has been used in western diets as a thickening adgent since the 1930’s.  There are two forms of carrageenan, degraded and undegraded, decided by their molecular weight.  Studies linking carrageenan to cancer are focused on the degraded form of carrageenan, which is not commonly used as a food additive.  The problem is, undegraded carrageenan is processed in a way that it can be contaminated with degraded carregeenan.  There may still be reason to avoid all carrageenan, even the undegraded form, because studies show it can cause inflammation in the gastrointestinal tract.  If you have Ulcerative Colitis, Chrons, or any other gastrointestinal diseases, I would be especially cautious of carrageenan in your food.
  • High Fructose Corn Syrup – All sugars should be limited in our diets, and high fructose corn syrup is no exception.  There is an on-going debate whether high fructose corn syrup is causing the obesity epidemic.  Princeton proved it may be the cause during a recent study.
Some other ingredients explained:
  • Gelatin vs. Pectin – Both are used to help thicken yogurts, gelatin is animal based and pectin is plant based.  Gelatin is derived from collagen found in ligaments, bones, and skin of animals.
  • Full fat vs. Low Fat or Fat Free – I guess that is a personal preference but the majority of studies show, full fat milk actually helps maintain healthy cholesterol levels, plus the natural fat in the milk helps our bodies digest the protein or absorb the calcium.
  • Carmine - while I guess it can be considered “natural”, carmine is a nice word for color from red beetles.  This can be found in Yoplait Strawberry Yogurt.
  • Modified Corn Starch - you will find this in many yogurts.  Most corn in our country is genetically modified, and then on top of that they modify the starch again to change the texture, or how it dissolves before adding it to the yogurt.  Unless it’s an organic company using corn products, or a company that is GMO-free it’s best to stay away from yogurts with corn starch.
  • Locust Bean Gum - this is not from a bug!  Locust bean gum is another name for carob bean gum, or carob gum, and is extract from seeds of a carob tree and used as a thickening agent.

There are so many brands and flavors of yogurt at the store, and it would be impossible to list them all.  I’m listing the one’s I can find at my local supermarkets.  Your best bet for clean yogurts — reading labels and buying plain yogurt (regular or greek, although greek has the better nutrition) and adding sweetener and fruit yourself.  I’m listing some safe, clean yogurts you can buy.  I will continue to update this list often so there are plenty of options.

DAIRY YOGURTS -

  • Atlanta Fresh Creamerythis yogurt is only offered regionally (south-east).  They get their milk from a small farm that is free from hormones and antibiotics, and the cows are primarily grass-fed.  They do not add any additives, and pride themselves on making high quality, fresh product.  They have a line of unique flavors like peach ginger, and black cherry & port wine, and offer Whole Milk, 2% Low-Fat, and Nonfat yogurts.
  • Chobani - they do not use milk from cows treated with rBST, and they do not add any food additives to their yogurts.  They have a variety of delicious flavors, but do not offer a full fat yogurt.  Five live active cultures can be found in their yogurts, some other brands only have two.  This is a great option even on a budget.
  • Voskosgreek yogurt company that offers full fat yogurts, which are additive,  rBST, and GMO free.
  • FAGE free from harmful additives but they do add corn starch as a thickener in some of their fruit flavored yogurts.  The milk they use is from cows that are not treated with rBGH (hormone).
  • Organic Yogurts – in general, organic dairy is the best and safest way to go, but carrageenan is allowed in organic products.  Just make sure you read the label if your yogurt is not listed.  One in particular to point out is Stonyfield.  While they are an organic company, they do add carrageenan to some of their yogurts – the caramel greek yogurt and YoKids Squeezers.  Their YoBaby yogurts are a great option, because they are organic and use whole milk.  They would even be a good option for adults looking to watch their portions.
DAIRY-FREE - 
  • Whole Soy – they use only organic, non-GMO soybeans to produce their yogurts.  Since they use soybeans, the yogurt has more protein than most other dairy-free alternatives.
  • Amande Yogurt - made from almond milk, and does not have carrageenan or any other additives.

How to Naturally Sweeten Plain Yogurt -

  • Add fresh or frozen fruit – if you use frozen fruit, simply take it out of the freezer and run it under room temperature water for one minute to defrost.
  • Homemade Granola is a great addition to yogurt
  • Dried Fruit, Nuts, and Coconut
  • Barlean’s Omega Swirl
  • Honey, agave, or maple syrup

Who didn’t make the list at my local supermarket - 

  • Dannon and Yoplait Yogurts – I left them ALL off the list, even though some do not have artificial additives.  The reason?  They use aspartame and food dyes in some of their yogurts.  I will not support any companies that use those additives and would urge you to do the same.

It can be difficult to decipher all the ingredients but I hope this guide helps you at the supermarket.  You have a lot of power as a consumer.  If you choose products without additives, not only are you making the right choice for you and your family but you are also supporting companies who care about the consumer.  Choose Wisely.
Facebook Twitter Email
Recent Articles

20 comments… read them below or add one

Kandice July 23, 2012 at 11:52 pm

Great work! I think the brand I get at Mother’s market is by Strauss. It’s organic & I usually buy the plain whole milk & add my own fruit. I also use it as a sub for sour cream. I have a hard time finding a larger sized plain, organic, greek yogurt from Mother’s. I can’t believe about the red beetles!!! Ps…tried the so delicious coconut yogurt but couldn’t handle the texture or taste!

Reply

Sarah Walker July 27, 2012 at 7:59 am

Thanks for the great info! I wrote Stoneyfield about the concern over the carageenan since my son loves YoKids. I think I will still switch him to something else, but I wanted to share their response in case anyone else was interested!

Thanks for reaching out to us with your concerns. We use undegraded
carrageenan in our YoKids Squeezers and caramel organic Oikos Greek yogurt
because it provides a necessary stability and texture to those particular
yogurts. We want to assure you that we choose our ingredients with safety
in mind. Carrageenan has been used widely in food production worldwide
since the 1930s, is on the National List of approved organic ingredients,
and has been assured by the FDA and the independent scientists of the Joint
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations/World Health
Organization Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA).

We’re also aware of the concerns that have been raised about carrageenan
during its recent review by the National Organic Standards Board. We took
those concerns very seriously, and engaged a scientist to conduct a review
of the literature about these possible health impacts. Based on this
independent review, along with the Board’s recommendation to continue to
allow it in organic production, we feel that carrageenan continues to be a
safe ingredient to use. You can read more about what we’ve learned and how
we arrived at our decision to continue using carrageenan here:
http://www.stonyfield.com/blog/2012/06/01/the-question-of-carageenan-safety/

We truly appreciate your feedback.

Sincerely,

The Folks at Stonyfield

Reply

greenplaterule July 27, 2012 at 1:49 pm

Hi Sarah,
I read the blog on Stonyfield’s website before I posted this blog. I was torn on whether carrageenan was something to be concerned about until reading that there can be traces of the degraded carrageenan mixed in with the undegraded type. I know they say it is only small traces of it, but I figure better safe than sorry, especially after reading so many articles saying there is reason for concern, and there are so many other options without carrageenan.
Thanks so much for sharing the email! I think Stonyfield is a very respectable company and overall has lots of great products to offer.

Reply

Amy August 15, 2012 at 8:35 am

What about Noosa yoghurt? The ingredient list seems pretty simple to me, but maybe I’m missing something?

Reply

greenplaterule August 15, 2012 at 9:41 pm

Hi Amy, I haven’t seen this brand at my store before. I did check on their website and I didn’t see anything added, so I believe it’s safe. Thanks for bringing another brand to my attention.

Reply

Meredith August 29, 2012 at 10:49 pm

Hi Victoria! I really enjoyed this post, I am just wondering why you didn’t mention anything about the large quantity of sugar in most greek yogurts. I know you said that you usually buy the plain but I noticed in one of your recent posts that you said you like the flavored Chobani greek yogurts and I think there is something like 20 grams of sugar in those individual serving containers. Just curious to hear what you think!

Reply

greenplaterule August 30, 2012 at 5:56 am

Hi Meredith, I did mention in the post buying plain yogurt was the best option but I know very few people actually make that choice. Chobani is higher in sugar, but they also have larger portions. The single serve portions from Voskos and Oikos are 5.3 oz and averaging 15 grams of sugar, where Chobani is 6 oz. and averaging 20 grams of sugar. Also, when you look at Chobani’s ingredients, in many cases the fruit is listed before sugar, meaning they add more real fruit than sugar, so more of the sugar is coming from natural sources. Most other yogurts (Oikos and Voskos included) have sugar listed before fruit. So yes, Chobani is higher in sugar, but it is justified.

Reply

Stacia August 30, 2012 at 10:48 am

I know you said you left Dannon off the list because of their ingredients use as a company. Just wondering what your thoughts would be on their new light & fit Greek yogurt. It has 7 grams of sugar and 12 grams of protein in a 5.3 oz serving. Would be curious to hear your opinion on this since I recently tried it with kind blueberry granola and loved it!

Reply

greenplaterule August 30, 2012 at 4:48 pm

Hi Stacia. Unfortunately Dannon Light & Fit Greek yogurt is not a good choice. All of those yogurts contain at least one of the following — artificial flavors, carmine, and modified corn starch (see post for more information). The also have preservatives, and use sucralose, which is an artificial sweetener.

Reply

Stacia September 6, 2012 at 12:26 pm

Thanks for the reply! I knew it had to be too good to be true!

Reply

Sugarmomma September 9, 2012 at 4:08 pm

Thank you for this insight on yogurt. The only thing that concerns me about most of the yogurts is that the sugar content is very high! Yes, plain is an option. Usually, I have to buy a larger container, add stevia, vanilla and fruit or granola so my kids will eat it. While this works fine, it is hard to have for a snack on-the-go for activities after school. :(

Reply

Anita January 14, 2013 at 4:10 pm

Hi Victoria,
I do alot of my shopping at Trader Joes and after reading this had to check my T.J. yogurts. Their tube yogurts “Squishers” also contain Carrageenan. Thanks for the heads up on this and good to know! Also thanks for shedding light on the corn starch additive. I had notice this was added to many flavored Greek Yogurts and it concerned me and left me feeling confused about what to buy. I only get organic but now I feel more empowered when shopping for yogurts!

Reply

Meaghan January 24, 2013 at 10:10 am

If any of you have a Shop-Rite around you, they have a great store-brand version of Greek Yogurt and it passes all of the tests! They are more than half the price of Chobani/Fage, at around 70cents each.

Reply

Tiffany February 4, 2013 at 5:18 pm

I am just starting the clean eats. What is the best yogurt to get? Which one is the safest should I say! I want to do this right.

Reply

greenplaterule February 7, 2013 at 12:21 am

In my opinion – if you eat dairy, the best would be an organic plain Greek yogurt. Flavor the yogurt yourself using real fruit, honey, stevia, or vanilla extract.

Reply

renee February 11, 2013 at 11:14 am

May I first say I am very excited about your sight. Very informative. The clean bread list was very helpful as there is so many choices and with three children in tow to the grocery store I found myself getting frusterated reading labels of the emense varieties of bread that are out there. Anyways, in regards to yogurt, I am in the Chicagoland area and found a brand called Mountain High. It uses pectin, 1% low fat milk, and the typical live and active cultures. That’s it! They also do not use milk from hormone cows. It is a great find in my opinion. I have a great “dreamsicle” smoothie recipe if you want me to share. The kids LOVE it!

Reply

Bethany February 24, 2013 at 11:37 am

I am really enjoying your site (which, of course, I found through Pinterest)! We do a lot of yogurt in our house both Stonyfield and homemade. My husband was diagnosed with Colitis over 10 years ago and has found immense benefits from “a yogurt a day” if its the right kind. I wanted to ask what you think about flavored yogurts and diminished bacterial affect. From what I’ve understood, as soon as a sugar is introduced, the good bacteria in yogurt is diminished. Therefore, fruit-on-the-bottom yogurt is better than blended yogurt because the fruit and sugars are kept separate. Do you know about this? What are your thoughts? I know many people eat yogurt because of the helpful bacteria so to me, this is an important consideration. Also, have you ever mentioned that different yogurts have different amounts and kinds of bacteria? Another thing to check the label for.

Reply

Gargi February 26, 2013 at 1:15 am

Hello Victoria,
First of all, I would like to say that I came across your website recently through Pinterest and can’t tell you how grateful I am to have discovered this. I want to ask you about a few things which I will do later but for now regarding this post, I wanted to inform you and many of the visitors of this website, it is very easy to make yoghurt at home. I am a girl of Indian origin and the way we make it is we let the milk come to a boil, then let it cool for about 30-45 mins and add a tbsp of already made yoghurt (I guess you can use the store bought yoghurt initially and then make sure you set aside a tbsp of your yoghurt before you finish it) and then let it ferment for a few hours. I usually stick mine in a warm toaster oven and voila its ready in 3-4 hours. My kids love yoghurt. It tastes different from store bought yoghurts but its homemade :)

Reply

Tina Monji March 9, 2013 at 8:54 pm

Hi everyone,
I appreciate this post very much! as a yogurt lover, it has been quite a journey for me to find a healthy option. I discovered Straus whole milk brand yogurt, and although it is sweetened, I buy the vanilla or pomegranate blueberry for the kids. Overall we have eliminated a lot of sweets, and they were NOT eating the plain. Even with honey, or syrup, or granola. sigh. baby steps. BUT, at Whole Foods, I discovered that Straus has a whole milk Greek yogurt. It is the BEST Greek yogurt I have ever had. I get about 4 servings out of each container, so I feel it’s a good value. Honey and my own granola make it perfect!!

Reply

Charlene March 11, 2013 at 3:20 pm

Hello Victoria,

I have also switched milks for my children after reading the article on aspartame. Is Oikos a wise decision in yogurt and the flavored ones? Thank you!

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: